| 1 | Kenda Bearclaw K299 ATV Tire – 25X8.00-12 By Kenda 350 Reviews | 9.7 Score | Average price… $60.48 |
| 2 | ITP Mud Lite XL Mud Terrain ATV Tire By ITP 63 Reviews | 9.5 Score | Average price… $98.87 |
| 3 | Carlisle AT489C ATV Tire – 25X10-12 By Carlisle 71 Reviews | 9.1 Score | Average price… $103.04 |
| 4 | ITP Mega Mayhem Mud Terrain ATV Tire 28×9-12 By ITP 50 Reviews | 9.0 Score | Average price… $121.07 |
| 5 | Kenda K284 K284 ATV Tire – 21X8-9 By Kenda 92 Reviews | 8.6 Score | Average price… $51.88 |
| 6 | Carlisle Turf Tamer ATV Tire – 25X12-9 By Carlisle 27 Reviews | 8.4 Score | Average price… $90.65 |
| 7 | ITP Mud Lite XTR Tire – Front/Rear By ITP 21 Reviews | 7.9 Score | Average price… $129.99 |
| 8 | ITP Blackwater Evolution Mud Terrain ATV Tire 2… By ITP 19 Reviews | 7.7 Score | Average price… $132.88 |
| 9 | Carlisle Mud Lite XTR All-Terrain ATV Radial Tire By Carlisle 18 Reviews | 7.5 Score | Average price… $121.63 |
| 10 | Carlisle Stryker ATV Tire – 22X11-8 By Carlisle 10 Reviews | 7.1 Score | Average price… $78.96 |